As a long time Leys Library user and grateful supporter, I, too, was shocked at the sudden closure in late December.
Richard Northey has claimed on your website that “....experts have found that it is no longer safe for public or staff for even a day longer.” This contradicts what Ian Maxwell, who made the decision on 19 December, stated that day, in his council’s release on the Our Auckland site, “There is no immediate risk to people currently using the buildings.” What is the true situation? Perhaps his admission in the NZH (17-1-20) that an option could be “selling the building to a developer to upgrade for other purposes” gives some clarity.
That same article has Ian Maxwell claiming that “library staff noticed shaking in the building.” I was at the library that day, and the next one when staff had to get their property out by 5pm. The staff were all quite shocked and bewildered as to why the closure decision was made. Since then I have also visited the library bus there, and over that whole period I spoke at length with many of the staff. None of them ever mentioned to me noticing shaking in the building. Perhaps Mr Maxwell is mistaken in his recollection on this matter?
Also, it has been asserted to John Elliott that council cannot undertake remedial work to the small area where cracks are present without also doing major seismic work to the whole building. However, my checking with an expert in this work has found that providing council puts forward a programme for seismic work, this can be progressed gradually over some years – possibly whilst the library and gym remain open. This was the case with the earlier strengthening.
At the minimum, council should postpone the intended stripping of the library books during February, whilst the reports are made public and the closure decision can undergo proper scrutiny. Simultaneously, Expressions of Interest could be called for to develop a programme and get some pricing for seismic work/repairs.
The buildings and the community services they provide are of such value that due process must be followed – and the generous and visionary gift from the Leys family can thus be respected and honoured. Readers interested in this matter could attend the next Waitemata Board meeting on 18 February where further questions will be raised. Bob Tait, Freemans Bay